MyRating: YYYY1/2Written and Directed by: Alan Mak & Felix ChongCast: Donnie Yen, Jiang Wen, Sun Li, Andy On, Chin Siu-ho, Alex Fong, Wang Po-chieh, Wang XuebingRomance of the Three Kingdoms (
San Guo Yan Yi), the popular
Chinese historical epic novel written by
Luo Guanzhong in the
14th century, is considered one of the
Four Great Classical Novels of
Chinese literature, besides
Water Margin (
Shui Hu Zhuan),
Journey to the West (
Xi You Ji) and
Dream of the Red Chamber (
Hong Lou Meng). As a hugely influential and widely read novel, based on the historical events (part fiction and myth) in the turbulent years at the end of the
Han Dynasty and the
Three Kingdoms era, where tyrants and warlords battling each others for power and lands (169-280 AD), the book consists of 120 chapters with hundreds and hundreds of characters. The story of the
Three Kingdoms has been told many times through long TV series as well as in movies. The recent ones are the critically acclaimed
John Woo's
Red Cliff (
2008) with
Tony Leung as
Zhou Yu &
Takeshi Kaneshiro as
Zhuge Liang, and the not so good
Three Kingdoms: Resurrection of the Dragon (
2008) with
Andy Lau as
Zhou Yun, which both movies focused on different main characters and events.
The Lost Bladesman focused on one of the most popular characters in the
Three Kingdoms story,
Guan Yu or
Guan Yunchang (one of the most iconic characters besides
Cao Cao,
Liu Bei &
Zhuge Liang). The film was adapted from the story of
Guan Yu 'crossing five passes and slaying six generals'. The casting of
Donnie Yen as
Guan Yu was an interesting choice, even though may have raised many eyebrows, since he is not physically perfect as the great
General Guan Yu.
Guan Yu is always depicted as a big tall guy with long beard, while
Yen is rather small in posture. However, since his recent superstardom and success through the
Ip Man series,
Donnie Yen has now become a household name and is on top of his game, and he is becoming the
'perfect' choice from every producer for the commercial success guarantee of their movies.

Since
Ip Man (
2008) &
Ip Man 2 (
2010), I am exciting to wait for every new movie of
Donnie Yen. Not only he is always amazing at martial arts in his movies (he knows the real
wushu), but also he is actually a pretty good actor too who can act very well (
even the sharp side look of his eyes could kill). A bit disappointed with his last movie
Legend of the Fist: The Return of Chen Zhen (
2010), but to see him next as
Guan Yu seemed to be very enticing. I have to admit, I began to have some doubts about this movie after seeing the relatively low rating this movie has received in some movie sites. However, after finally watching the movie myself, I have to say that my feeling and pre-judgement were totally wrong. This is a great epic martial arts film about the legendary
Guan Yu and one small part of the events in the
Three Kingdoms story, disregard the disputes that it might create among the audiences due to the different interpretation of
Guan Yu's figure this movie has depicted. Anyway, a good movie is
a good movie, and I will tell you why I like this movie.
The Lost Bladesman offered a pretty good and solid story. Being separated from his sworn brothers
Liu Bei (
Alex Fong) and
Zhang Fei,
Guan Yu (
Yen) temporarily had to serve under
Cao Cao (
Jiang Wen) and
Emperor Xian (
Wang Po-chieh) of
Han Dynasty. With the big name and reputation that
Guan Yu had in the battlefields,
Cao Cao had always wanted to have him on his side. But despite many precious gifts that
Cao Cao had offered to
Guan Yu, including recommended an honorary rank promotion from the
Emperor after
Guan Yu won a battle for
Cao Cao against
Yuan Shao,
Cao Cao still could not buy
Guan Yu's loyalty towards
Liu Bei.

When
Guan Yu decided that it was time to leave
Cao Cao and bring
Qilan (
Betty Sun Li),
Liu Bei's beautiful concubine who was captived in
Cao Cao territory, back to
Liu Bei,
Cao Cao knew that he had to let him go. But
Cao Cao's followers were uneasy and believed that they were actually realising a
'tiger' back to his master
, who would become a dangerous threat to
Cao Cao in the future. So on their journey back,
Guan Yu and
Qilan had to face some generals and their bands of soldiers, who were ordered to kill
Guan Yu, in the passes that they were going through. And
Guan Yu fought many magnificent fights against the generals. Not only he had to stay alive, but also he had to protect
Qilan, his brother's woman, whom at the same time he secretly falled in love with, but he tried hard to resist.
The great Guan Yu will never afraid of his enemies, but will the love of a woman become the weakness of him?
The script written (and also directed) by
Alan Mak (
Infernal Affairs)&
Felix Chong, even though not the best ever written about the
Three Kingdoms events, was engaging and never lost its grips from the beginning till the end. I think the story was actually simple and it did not try to complicate itself, by focusing on
Guan Yu and his task to bring
Qilan back to
Liu Bei, while at the other hand showing the
'situational' friendship bound between
Guan Yu and
Cao Cao, which is very interesting to watch. The forbidden love attraction between
Guan Yu and
Qilan did spice up the plot, as the audiences may feel sympathy and
'secretly' wish that
Guan Yu, after all the sacrifices and the never ending battles that he has to fight along their journey, will finally win
not only her heart, but also win
Qilan in person as a whole, with the hope of blessing from
Liu Bei to reward for his loyalty.
Or not? If you are seeing
Guan Yu as a man of honor and dignity, who will never betray his brother for whatsoever reasons. This issue will provoke the acceptance sensess from the audiences, since never before we see
Guan Yu so 'human', as he is always being pictured as a tough man and a
god-like hero.

The martial arts sequences were dazzling and top notch, giving credits to
Donnie Yen as the
Action Director himself. Except the big battle scene in the beginning of the movie, you may not see many fights of
Guan Yu in the big open battlefields, instead you will see
Guan Yu fighting some generals and their small groups of soldiers along his journey back to
Liu Bei, some were
'one-on-one' fight scenes. The most marvelous one was the
1-on-1 fight scene in the narrow town alley between
Guan Yu and
Kong Xiu (
Andy On), the general defending
Dongling pass. It was an amazing acrobatic showcase of
Guan Yu's famous
Green Dragon crescent-moon blade weapon against
Kong Xiu's long spear. An excellent
heart-pumping martial arts choreography by
Yen. The fight scene when
Guan Yu and
Qilan were being ambushed in
Luoyang by
Han Fu and his sworn brother
Meng Tan and their bunch of soldiers in a house at night was also a dramatic one, where
Guan Yu was poisoned while he has to give a great fight and kept himself from being fainted. Another memorable scene was the uneven
1-on-1 fight between
Guan Yu and
Wang Zhi (
Wang Xuebing), a
good official in charge of
Xingyang, in an empty town near the end of the movie. If you like martial arts movie, there are plenty of terrific action scenes that will keep you amazed on your seat.

The other thing that I liked about this movie was the very good and smart written dialogues, with many
Chinese aphorisms and
wise sayings. The old
Chinese wise sayings are arguably the best
wise sayings in the world literature with very deep meaning behind every
sayings, sometimes in a very poetic way. Watching a
Chinese movie with rich
Chinese wise-sayings does give intellectual challenges and satisfactions, as if you are a
Chinese scholar yourself. And I consider the dialogues in this movie as one of those that will enrich and satisfy us intellectually.

And finally, the casting. It was, without a doubt, a great cast. Not only
Donnie Yen, but also
Jiang Wen (
Let the Bullets Fly), one of the most versatile
Chinese actor nowadays (also a director/writer/producer). As
Cao Cao, who in history was known for his cunningness,
Jiang Wen gave a solid performance that also colored the character of
Cao Cao to become more 'human', but at the same time, a more complex character. In this movie,
Cao Cao was not shown one-side as a totally bad guy, but he has
heart, and definitely the brain. His dialogues with
Guan Yu were always interesting ones, with his
wide-range mimics.
Jiang Wen is indeed a very good actor. While as
Guan Yu, again even though not matched physically,
Donnie Yen also gave a pretty good performance. A different
Guan Yu, but I didn't mind at all. Pick another actor that fit the physical characteristics of
Guan Yu, and you may not get the same excitements as you get with
Donnie Yen in it. In a story dominated by males,
Sun Li was thrown in to sweeten the screen with her beauty as
Qilan, and complicate the story.

Standout casts, enjoyable storyline and spectacular martial arts.
What more could you expect? And I know that I loved this movie more than I expected. Very entertaining and a must see. While I was writing this, I found out that
The Lost Bladesman has made a very successful debut at the box office in
China, which earned around
110 million yuan (
US$ 17 million) in the first week in
China itself, since its opening date on
April 26, 2011. Seems to be a pretty solid hit.

Nowadays,
Guan Yu is still popularly worshipped and paid respect by the
Chinese people. Being referred as
Guan Gong or '
Lord Guan' or
'Saintly Emperor Guan',
Guan Yu is often considered as the
God of War due to his status as the
'great general' and the many military successes in the history.
Guan is also
worshipped as an alternative
'god of wealth', as he is perceived to bless people (as well as their homes and businesses) and protect people from the wicked.
(MJ)